The Freeman Examiner
Pertinent News & Discourse
Much to the dismay of the average teenager, the Pythagorean theorem and natural selection are required elements of a high-school education. But when it comes to the classics of literature like "Brave New World" and "To Kill a Mockingbird," the lines begin to blur.
Campaigns for wholesale bans on these and other classic works make occasional headlines, but many students are barred from reading such books through a simple request from a parent.
The question of how often this happens, and whether the practice should be allowed, is forcing its way into public debate following a controversy at the country's largest school board, where a formal policy allows students to opt out.
Map of Canada: M A P (GeographyIQ.com)
No work of literature is mandatory at Toronto's public schools: Parents can simply ask the principal to excuse their children from reading any book. And no one knows which books are substituted or how often because no one keeps a tally.
No such anonymity attended the battle over Boo Radley that burst out last week.
Line Pinard has received just two complaints in her six years as high-school principal.
The first complaint, near the beginning of her tenure at Malvern Collegiate Institute, was about Russell Banks's "Rule of the Bone." It was settled quietly when the parent agreed that the child could read W.O. Mitchell's "Who Has Seen the Wind" instead.
The second complaint put her under the microscope when reports emerged that the school and the board were considering a ban on To Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee. (Those who jumped to conclusions could perhaps be forgiven - the Pulitzer-Prize-winning classic was removed from the curriculum at a high school in Brampton, Ont., just months ago.) In fact, a parent had merely raised a complaint with Ms. Pinard about the book's language, and had suggested "The Book of Negroes" by Lawrence Hill as a suitable alternative for the Grade 10 curriculum.
The parent's child isn't even in Grade 10, Ms. Pinard noted.
That didn't stifle the outcry. Staff lined up outside her office pleading the case for Boo Radley and Calpurnia. Ms. Picard's inbox was flooded with page-long e-mails from parents who had written veritable dissertations on the life lessons contained within the book.
"You can't imagine the hours I've spent on this," Ms. Pinard said.
This week school trustees will be asked to debate the policy anew.
"I think that we're setting a precedent where we're allowing some parents to micromanage a public system that's supposed to be delivering a common curriculum," said trustee Josh Matlow, who plans to appeal the policy at a board meeting on Wednesday.
"My concern here is that I think we're being very politically correct," Mr. Matlow said. "It's a very interesting discussion: What is the line between intolerance and acceptance, and then the line where we are not supporting our basic values as a progressive society."
But parents and students should question the literature they're asked to read, and their right to object deserves to be protected, said Dianne Fenner, program co-ordinator of English and literacy for the Toronto board.
Earlier this year Margaret Atwood's T he Handmaid's Tale was challenged by a parent, but a TDSB review committee voted to keep the book as part of the high-school curriculum.
Giving parents the right to exclude their children avoids appeals for school-wide or board-wide bans, and amounts to the lesser of two evils, said Franklin Carter, an editor and researcher of the Freedom of Expression Committee of the Book and Periodical Council.
"The school board has to do something. We're never going to get to the point where no one ever complains, so I think that this is the situation that we're stuck with," he said.
There is potential for abuse, but his group has neither the manpower nor the financial resources to keep closer tabs on book censorship in Canada, he said. Mr. Carter works from media reports to keeps track of some of the loudest objections.
Murielle Boudreau, co-chair of the Greater Toronto Catholic Parent Network, said that exposing children to controversial books gives parents an opportunity to discuss important issues at home.
"If it's out there, in my opinion it's better to expose the child and explain whatever it is, rather than not to expose them," she said. "If you really have objections you should do home schooling."
Article found online at: Link… (TheGlobeAndMail.com)
Source files zipped here: Saved (FreemanExaminer.org)
The Freeman Examiner is a premier aggregator of information on socio-political issues and events; emphasis is given to revealing the actions and intrigues of Government and Big Business, so that the public may better protect themselves from incompetence, manipulation or tyranny in any form.
COPYRIGHT by author or current publisher. The Freeman Examiner cannot ensure the accuracy, fairness or completeness of the material posted here, nor does this website support or endorse any specific party, movement or commercial interest; the news, discourse and links found here are provided only as an informative service to the public.
Contact the Fmx Editor at: http://freemanexaminer.org/misc/contact.php
=> For more topics, use the Search box at the top of the page...
Feature
Recent Headlines
Black-on-Black Culture Clash - 'African'-Americans unwilling to accept real Africans...
IBM proposes controlled cities - Using high-tech to curb traffic, crime... dissent...
The name's Mussolini... Benito Mussolini - Dictator got start with help from British intelligence service...
Critical Curriculum: African Heritage - Challenging the racist, white supremacist school system...
Refugees of Diversity - Whites are fleeing to small, distant, homogeneous communities...
Globally-Acceptable Truth - Controlling what we think, even how we think...
Dollars, trade and labor - Implications of the new emerging economic order...
The Great Clothesline Debate - Local ordinances against drying your clothes outside...
Beijing fights online disharmony - Censorship losing ground to high-tech communications...
The artist Muslims love to hate - Cartoonist of 'Muhammad wearing turban-bomb' visits US...
Naked airport babes! - England trying 'see-through-clothes' scanners...
What kids read in school - Forced curriculum vs. parental rights...
'Chemical castration' for sex offenders - Why not use drugs to dampen their libido for a while?
Obama, Fascism and Color - On having The Left protect us from whom they got elected...
A hostile takeover of Zionism - The once-secular state of Israel is becoming a theocracy...
For more topics use the Search box at the top of the page...
Reciprocal Links
"Comforting the afflicted and afflicting the comfortable..."
"Commentary on Politics, Economics, and Military Affairs"
